This week's materials focused on Virtual Learning, which encompasses the use of online learning management systems like Blackboard for students to for engagement in a Virtual School environment. Davis & Niederhauser (2007) addressed that In the K-12 Online experience there is an interrelated connectivity web of support for all participants involved in online learning. There are extended participants outside of the expected teacher and student roles i.e. the On-Site Facilitators: for administrators and parents to support students, Instructional technology Coordinators: for student technical needs, and Course Designers: to collaborate with the online teachers for course development. The OCDSB videos were informative, but a bit frustrating to view due to the distracting background noises from the intercom. Some E-Learning challenges addressed by the instructor in this video series were tracking students, maintaining communication, and providing effective and timely feedback to students. Some of the perks of E-Learning addressed were flexibility and the teacher motivation to engage with the students. Borup et. al (2009) provides insight into the differences between teacher engagement and teacher presence. For the success of K-12 requirements engagement is required for success. The availability of a teacher is not enough for students. to succeed. They must all be engaged with their students regardless if instruction is face-to-face or virtual. Teachers roles of importance for k-12 online-learning are "nurturing, motivating and monitoring" in comparison the indicators of presence "designing/organizing, facilitating discourse, and providing direct instruction". The overall study needs some refinement, but student avoidance or disengagement seemed to be an issue the study could not overcome in some instances. While teachers felt more motivated to engage, they could not always determine how to motivate students who may try to avoid teacher interaction all together.
(Five Things: Blackboard vs. Canvas)
The Archambault & Crippen (2009) analyzes the demographics of some instructors for K-12 Online programs. This article also addressed the increasing statistics of online enrollment in the K-12 level from multiple sources with the consistent factor being an influx of enrollments, with a higher level focused on the high school level. Highlighted advantages of online classes in this article included growing student populatuons, limited space, scheduling conflicts, and so forth. The age of instructors in these course were highly concentrated in the 26 to 35 years old age bracket with a gradual decline in instructors and the age ranges increased. I was surprised to see that less that 3% of online instructors were within the 21 to 25 years old age bracket. Many of the instructors in this study were female (77%) in constrast to males (23%). The majority of instructors had at least a Bachelor's degree (92%), while more than half also possessed a master's degree (62%). In regards to race 91% were white/Caucasian. This study providing the statistics needed regarding the population of instructors in the K-12 that did not previously exist to this extent.
Why is it important?
Surprisingly, of the nine teachers in the Borup et. al (2009) study most
of the teachers founds parents were more proactive with communicating
in comparison to face-to-face courses. Two teachers who bought
pre-designed courses were frustrated, because they could not alter the
materials, which also caused a feeling of disconnection with the
materials. Another interesting fact from this study was the anti-bullying training OHSU initiated. In the online instructor field, I did not consider cyber bullying as a threat to the learning environment within the LMS. The Archambault & Crippen (2009) article statistics addresses the disparities of age, gender, education levels, and race amongst the
instructors of K-12 courses and this is notable information. These differences
may lead to project why, some of the instructors may fair better at
connecting with and motivating their students in the K-12 VS
environment, especially while using various technology tools. The OCDSB videos provide first hand experience that reinforces information provided by the reading materials from this week.
How can I use this information?
Davis & Niederhauser (2007) disseminated the components of Virtual Learning--from the tools and all the participants involved. For example, I was not aware of course shells existing prior to reading the Davis article. Previously, I thought all online instructors created all of their own course materials. In the future, I may possibly consider reviewing ESL course shells for reference of the components available for online ESL students. The struggles that instructors in the Borup (2009) encountered with pre-designed made me realized self-designed courses will be better to teach my students. In this scenario, at least I can modify materials as needed. I will need to ensure my students receive effective and efficient feedback and try to foster an high level of motivation and engagement in my future online courses. The Archambault & Crippen (2009) data provides information that may help me to understand my cohort of instructors and to address issues students connection and motivation within the VS environment through collaboration. As an online instructor, I will need to be organized, highly engaged with my students, and impactful to their motivation.
Your thoughts regarding predesigned materials is spot-on. Now, consider you work for a district/program that is insisting, for example, on using something like Pearson for predesigned materials. How would you convince them that this is not in the best interest of the students or teachers?
I would address the disconnection many teachers would feel from the course materials. Another issue is that pre-designed course materials may prevent teachers from addressing certain questions, students may have about the coursework. Teachers/Faculty members who design courses would be able to address navigation/submission questions. In contrast teachers who were unfamiliar with the LMS would not be able to answers these questions. In addition, teachers may feel stressed or less motivated from not owning/developing at least some of their course materials/assignments.
What did I learn? This week’s materials focused on the impact of technology in the classroom and on the development of adolescent minds. In the Hawkins, Barbour, and Graham article (2012) it discusses how deep, meaningful learning experiences through the Community of Inquiry (COI) framework are fostered when the teachers and students interact in an online environment. An interplay between social, cognitive, and teaching presence is needed to promote this experience. Objectives must be clearly communicated, application of studies is needs, and an experience of community is solidified through this method amongst student peers. The difficulties experiences through the online environment are that some teachers feel isolated from their cohort or worry about office hours with students due to flexible scheduling conflicts. By being aware of these issues of disconnection a sense of community between teachers and student through conscientious efforts. Borup and Stevens (2...
What did I learn? The reading materials from this week were collectively informative in relation to statistics and challenges for online learning. Evergreen Education Group (2019) identified trends for the pool of K-12 online learners, which included higher enrollment rates for female students, and students in grades 8-12. Within in this report an incline for students in world language course was also noted. The “urban legends” noted in the Kirschner et. al (2013) report digital natives, self-educators, and specific learning styles were all refuted as notions widely accepted without evidence. Kirschner et. al (2013) explained in depth why these “urban legends” or assumptions are untrue to including information to demerit the multitasking of millennial students, due to the many disruptions/distraction they are surrounded by in their environments. Evergreen (2011) explained the dimensions of online programs and focused on the demographics of online learners. Kennedy (U...
Your thoughts regarding predesigned materials is spot-on. Now, consider you work for a district/program that is insisting, for example, on using something like Pearson for predesigned materials. How would you convince them that this is not in the best interest of the students or teachers?
ReplyDeleteI would address the disconnection many teachers would feel from the course materials. Another issue is that pre-designed course materials may prevent teachers from addressing certain questions, students may have about the coursework. Teachers/Faculty members who design courses would be able to address navigation/submission questions. In contrast teachers who were unfamiliar with the LMS would not be able to answers these questions. In addition, teachers may feel stressed or less motivated from not owning/developing at least some of their course materials/assignments.
Delete